The complexity of Israel's hostage predicament: balancing humanity and national security - opinion

As Israel grapples with the aftermath of October 7, the ethical and strategic dilemmas surrounding hostage negotiations intensify, raising real questions about balancing lives and national security.

Hostages who were abducted by Hamas on October 7 are escorted by the International Red Cross, as part of a hostages-prisoners swap with Israel on November 30. The Red Cross has been notably negligent in its mission, the writer charges.

(photo credit: Hamas Military Wing/Handout via REUTERS)

ByYISRAEL MEDAD

JULY 25, 2024 05:45

Updated: JULY 25, 2024 05:56

RECOMMENDED STORIES

Palestinian Hamas terrorists keep guard on the day Hamas handed over deceased hostages in Khan Younis in the southern Gaza Strip February 20, 2025.

Admitting defeat? Why Hamas officials say the terror group 'lost control' of Gaza

JULY 7, 2025

Members of Hamas with the backdrop of the Gaza Strip, amid reports that Hamas has lost control of much of its territory.

'Security situation has collapsed': Hamas has lost 80% of its control over Gaza Strip

JULY 7, 2025

Reporter's Notebook: 'Post' meets with top Hebron sheikh who wants to pull out of PA

JULY 6, 2025

IDF Maj.-Gen. Aviad Dagan entering a fighter jet; illustrative.

IDF cyber chief, retired Iran strategy head piloted fighter jets striking Iran

JULY 6, 2025

Hot Opinion

War doesn't end on the battlefield: Israel must better support veterans with PTSD

ByJPOST EDITORIAL

Iran at a crossroads: Intelligence breaches, internal paranoia shake the regime

BySALEM ALKETBI

Is an Iran nuclear deal still possible after the US-Israel strikes?

ByCHUCK FREILICH

Paying for the 'day after': Who will fund Gaza’s reconstruction?

ByNEVILLE TELLER